Seafood Systems

What Seafood Sustainability Labels Actually Verify

What Seafood Sustainability Labels Actually Verify
Guest Contributor

Guest Contributor

Contributor

10 min read

Two blue labels sit on the seafood counter. One carries a stylized fish, the other a different stylized fish. Both say something about sustainability, both are widely trusted, and most shoppers treat them as interchangeable endorsements of the same idea.

They are not interchangeable, and the reason goes deeper than one covering wild fish and the other covering farmed. The two schemes certify fundamentally different things, using different logic, against different risks. Understanding that distinction is the most useful thing a buyer can know, and it leads directly to the question the carousel closes on: what a label verifies, and what it leaves out.

 

Two Labels, Two Different Units of Assessment

 

The Marine Stewardship Council certifies fisheries. The Aquaculture Stewardship Council certifies farms. That sounds like a simple division of territory, but the two units behave completely differently.

In MSC terms, a fishery is not a company and not a boat. It is a particular stock of fish, caught with a particular gear type, under a particular management regime. The same species in the same ocean can be a certified fishery when caught one way and an uncertified one when caught another. What is being assessed is partly the fish population itself and partly the governance system around it, neither of which any single operator controls. A fishery's certification therefore depends substantially on whether the relevant government or regional management body is doing its job.

An ASC certificate attaches to a specific farm site, an operation with an owner, a boundary, and a manager. Everything inside it is controllable: stocking density, feed, chemical use, effluent, escapes, labor conditions. Certification assesses how well a known operator runs a known facility.

This mirrors the underlying environmental problem in each sector. Capture fisheries risk taking too much from a shared system nobody owns. Aquaculture risks putting too much into the surrounding environment from an operation someone does own. The certification schemes are shaped by that difference, which is why they could not simply be merged.

 

What Each One Actually Assesses

 

MSC assessment rests on three principles: that the stock is healthy enough to sustain fishing indefinitely, that the fishery's impact on the wider ecosystem, including bycatch and habitat, is acceptable, and that the management system is effective and responsive.

The standard has recently tightened. MSC Fisheries Standard version 3.0, launched in October 2022 after four years of review and more than 600 stakeholder submissions, applies to all new certifications from May 2023, with existing fisheries given up to six years to transition. It introduced a stricter definition of endangered, threatened, ed and protected species with greater protections for them, a new policy aimed at providing confidence that shark finning is not occurring in certified fisheries, explicit responsibilities for preventing and reducing lost fishing gear, stronger monitoring and surveillance requirements particularly on the high seas, and stronger requirements for international agreement on harvest strategies for shared stocks.

That six-year transition matters when reading a label today. A product carrying the MSC mark in 2026 may come from a fishery certified under the previous standard, with a few years still to run before it must meet the new one. The label looks identical either way.

ASC has undergone a major structural change. Its previously separate species standards for salmon, shrimp, bivalves, tilapia, and others have been consolidated into a single global Farm Standard launched in 2025, covering environmental performance, social responsibility, fish health and welfare, and farm management in one cross-species framework. The first farm certified directly to it was Lubimar, a seabass and seabream operation in Cádiz, Spain, on 30 March 2026, with established producers including Bakkafrost beginning their transitions. ASC now also requires certified farms to use ASC-conforming feed, in force since 31 October 2025, extending the standard's reach back into the feed supply chain and partly addressing the long-standing criticism that certifying a farm says nothing about what is in the bags delivered to it.

The scale is worth noting on both sides. ASC reported 2,543 certified farms across 51 countries in 2025, producing more than 2.9 million tonnes, up 9 percent year on year, alongside 91 certified feed mill sites in 27 countries. MSC reported 789 fisheries engaged with its program as of March 2026, accounting for 19.5 percent of global wild marine catch, of which 18.4 percent was certified, representing around 15.46 million tonnes of engaged catch and over 22,000 labeled products on sale.

 

Who Checks, and Who Pays Them

 

The carousel's third slide says independent auditors examine fishing practices or farming operations, which is accurate and worth unpacking, because the structure contains a tension that applies to every certification scheme ever built.

Neither MSC nor ASC performs its own audits. They set standards and accredit third-party conformity assessment bodies, which do the assessment work. That separation exists deliberately, so that the organization setting the rules does not also decide who passes.

The unresolved part is that the fishery or farm seeking certification pays the auditor. The auditor's client is the entity being audited. This is the same structure as financial auditing, credit ratings, and the second-party opinions that underpin green and blue bonds, and it carries the same well-documented pressures: a conformity body that fails clients too often finds fewer clients. Accreditation oversight, standardized methodologies, and objection procedures exist to manage this, and the objections process has genuinely blocked or delayed certifications. But the incentive is structural rather than a matter of individual integrity, and it is the main reason independent scrutiny of certified fisheries keeps producing findings that audits did not.

 

Chain of Custody Carries More Weight Than It Appears To

 

The fourth slide points at something that deserves to be treated as central rather than as a postscript.

Certification at the point of catch or harvest is worthless if the product that reaches a shelf is not the product that was certified. Certified and uncertified fish of the same species are physically identical, and a fillet reveals nothing about which boat caught it. The only thing preventing substitution is a documentary and physical control system: segregating certified product in storage and processing, records at every transfer of ownership, and periodic audits of those records.

The number of transfers is the problem. Between a vessel and a plate there may be a landing agent, a primary processor, a cold store, an exporter, an importer, a secondary processor, a distributor and a retailer, often crossing several jurisdictions. Each of those is a point where the paperwork must be right. Research into the final stages of the supply chain in the United States has found certified seafood and federal labeling requirements working against each other at the point of sale, with the end of the chain the weakest part.

This is why chain-of-custody certification is a separate certificate with its own audits, and why a label on a package implies a verified claim about every handler in between, not just the fishery or farm.

 

What a Label Does Not Cover

 

The carousel's conclusion, that certification covers defined standards rather than every impact, is the correct one and can be made specific.

Neither scheme certifies carbon footprint. A fishery can be MSC certified while using one of the most fuel-intensive gear types, because fuel use is not within the standard's scope. Neither scheme assesses the nutritional or dietary merits of eating that species. MSC does not assess fish welfare in any meaningful sense, which is a growing issue for consumers if not yet for the standard. And neither scheme attempts to judge whether a species should be fished or farmed at all, only whether a given operation meets defined criteria.

Scope limits are not a flaw. A standard that promised to cover everything would be unauditable. The flaw arises when the label is read as a general endorsement rather than as a specific claim, and that gap between what is certified and what is inferred is where the current pressure on these schemes is concentrated.

 

The 2026 Challenge

 

That pressure has become concrete, and anyone writing about seafood labels now has to account for it.

In June 2026, Make Stewardship Count, a coalition of more than 90 marine conservation organizations and researchers, published Beyond Certification. Its central argument targets retailers rather than shoppers: relying principally on MSC certification does not protect a company from legal, investor, or stakeholder action. It does not satisfy obligations under the OECD Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises. The report cites research linking forced labor to MSC-certified supply chains, criticism of certified Antarctic krill fisheries, and a set of live cases including action against Carrefour under the French Corporate Duty of Vigilance Law concerning MSC-labelled tuna, an OECD complaint and shareholder action against Woolworths Group in Australia partly over reliance on certification for farmed salmon, and multiple US class actions over sustainability claims on certified products. Its recommendation to the MSC is that it drop "sustainable" claims and state plainly that certification is not a substitute for comprehensive due diligence.

The MSC's position is that certification is a rigorous, science-based, independently audited assessment against a standard that has just been strengthened, that an imperfect mechanism covering nearly a fifth of global wild catch achieves more than no mechanism at all, and that the objections process gives critics a formal route to challenge individual certifications.

Both positions can be true simultaneously, and the most useful way to hold them together is this: certification is a floor, not a ceiling, and the problem is that it has been marketed as a ceiling. A retailer treating a logo as the end of its due diligence is making a commercial and increasingly a legal mistake. A shopper treating it as better-than-nothing information is reading it correctly.

 

The Coverage Problem Underneath

 

One structural point sits beneath all of this and deserves stating, because it limits how much certification can ever achieve.

MSC's 18.4 percent of global wild marine catch is a substantial achievement, nd it means more than 80 percent is uncertified. The uncertified majority is not randomly distributed. It is disproportionately small-scale, tropical, and operating in jurisdictions with limited stock assessment, weak enforcement, and no capacity to fund the assessment process in the first place, which is precisely where the worst outcomes occur.

Certification works best where management is already functioning, because the standard largely measures whether management is functioning. It is therefore good at confirming and rewarding good practice and structurally poor at reaching the fisheries where intervention would matter most. That is not a criticism of either organization. It is an argument that certification is one instrument among several, alongside fisheries management reform, import controls, traceability regulation and transparency requirements, none of which it can substitute for.

 

How to Read a Label Honestly

 

The carousel's closing advice is right, and the practical version runs roughly as follows.

Treat the two labels as answering different questions, because they do. Read MSC as a claim about a stock, a gear type and a management system, and ASC as a claim about a specific farm's operations. Understand that both are assessed against defined criteria that exclude carbon, most welfare considerations, and any judgment about whether the species should be eaten. Remember that chain of custody is doing a great deal of unglamorous work to make the claim mean anything at the till. And note that the absence of a label indicates a lack of assessment rather than poor performance, since most of the world's seafood has never been assessed by anyone.

A label is evidence, not a verdict. It narrows the uncertainty considerably, and it does not eliminate it, which is a less satisfying conclusion than a blue tick implies and a more accurate one.

 

Note: This article reflects the state of seafood certification as of November 2026, drawing on sources including the MSC Annual Report 2025-26, MSC Fisheries Standard version 3.0 documentation, the ASC 2025 Impact Report and Farm Standard materials, and the June 2026 Beyond Certification report published by Make Stewardship Count. A companion piece in this series compares wild-caught and farmed seafood more broadly.

Share this article
Guest Contributor

Guest Contributor

Contributor

This article was contributed by an external writer affiliated with our publication.