Can the Ocean's Tides Generate Electricity?

Guest Contributor
Contributor
Yes, and a plant in Brittany has been doing it since 1966. The La Rance barrage has generated electricity from the tides for sixty years, which makes tidal power older as a commercial technology than the modern wind industry.
That fact sits awkwardly beside another: global tidal capacity today is measured in hundreds of megawatts, while wind and solar are measured in terawatts. A technology with a six-decade head start has gone almost nowhere, and the reasons are specific and instructive, not a matter of neglect. The carousel's final question is the right one, and the UK's electricity auctions now provide an unusually precise answer.
Why Water Beats Air, and Why That Is Not Enough
The physics looks extraordinarily favorable at first glance. Seawater is around 830 times denser than air, and the power available in a moving fluid scales directly with density. For the same rotor area and the same flow speed, water carries roughly 830 times the energy.
The complication is the rest of the equation. Power scales with the cube of velocity, and velocity is where wind wins decisively. A good offshore wind site sees 10 to 15 meters per second. A world-class tidal site runs at 2.5 to 5 meters per second at peak flow. Cubing those numbers largely cancels the density advantage.
What survives is a real but narrower benefit: a tidal turbine extracts comparable power from a far smaller machine. MeyGen's turbines are around 18 meters in rotor diameter for roughly 1.5 megawatts each. A modern offshore wind turbine producing 15 megawatts has a rotor diameter above 230 meters. Tidal devices are compact, which matters when every component must survive permanent immersion in salt water.
Tidal Stream: Underwater Turbines
The carousel's description is exact. A tidal stream turbine works like an underwater wind turbine: flowing water spins blades that drive a generator, and the devices work only where currents are strong.
How strong is the binding constraint? Economic operation generally requires peak spring flows above roughly 2.5 meters per second, and that does not occur in open ocean. It occurs where a tidal wave is forced through a constriction: a narrow strait, a channel between islands, a passage around a headland. The Pentland Firth between mainland Scotland and Orkney, the Bay of Fundy, the straits around the Korean peninsula and the channels off Anglesey are examples, and the list of genuinely good sites worldwide is short.
This is the single most important difference between tidal stream and the renewables it is compared with. Wind blows almost everywhere, and the sun shines almost everywhere, so those industries could scale by building the same machine in thousands of locations. Tidal stream resources are concentrated in a small number of physically constrained channels, which caps the total market regardless of how good the technology becomes. The UK's practical tidal stream resource has been estimated at around 34 terawatt hours a year, equivalent to about 11.5 gigawatts installed or roughly 11 percent of national demand. That is meaningful, and it is a ceiling.
Tidal Range: The Dam Approach
A barrage works on height rather than speed. Build a dam across an estuary, let it fill on the flood tide, hold the water, then release it through turbines as the tide falls, generating from the head difference. It is hydroelectricity with the Moon operating the reservoir.
Two significant plants exist. La Rance in France, 240 megawatts, commissioned in 1966. Sihwa Lake in South Korea, 254 megawatts, commissioned in 2011 and now the world's largest tidal power station.
Sihwa is the more instructive of the two, because it explains why there are not more of them. The seawall was not built for power generation. It was constructed for land reclamation, and it created an enclosed lagoon that became severely polluted. Adding turbines restored water exchange, improving water quality, and the capital cost of the most expensive component, the dam itself, had already been incurred for another purpose. Sihwa was affordable because the hardest part was already paid for.
Where that is not the case, the economics have repeatedly failed. The Severn Estuary has the second-largest tidal range in the world, and proposals there have ranged from 1 to 15 gigawatts. In 2010, the UK government concluded there was no strategic case for a barrage of roughly ten miles costing more than 30 billion pounds. The smaller Swansea Bay tidal lagoon, at 1.3 billion pounds, was judged not to represent value for money despite Welsh Government support. A commission was established in 2022 to revisit the Severn question, and nothing has been built.
The environmental objection to barrages is also categorically different from the one facing tidal stream. A barrage alters the tidal regime of an entire estuary, reducing the intertidal area that is exposed and covered each day. In the Severn, those mudflats support internationally protected bird populations, and no amount of turbine design addresses that. Tidal stream turbines sit in open flow and raise narrower questions about collision risk, noise, and electromagnetic fields, where evidence from operating sites has so far been more reassuring than early modeling suggested.
Predictable Is Not the Same as Firm
The carousel's fourth slide is careful, and the care is warranted, because the predictability argument is often overstated.
Orbital mechanics drives tides so that they can be computed decades in advance with great accuracy. That is genuinely different from wind and solar, where forecasting degrades beyond a few days. A tidal operator knows precisely when peak generation will occur in March 2041.
That does not mean steady output. Flow goes to zero at slack water, four times a day, and generation goes with it. On top of the daily cycle sits the spring-neap cycle of roughly fourteen days, driven by the alignment of Sun and Moon, during which peak flow speeds can vary by a factor of two or more. Because power scales with velocity cubed, a neap tide can produce a small fraction of the energy of a spring tide at the same site.
So tidal is predictable and variable, not predictable and firm. The system value lies in the predictability itself: a generator whose output is known in advance imposes far lower balancing and reserve costs on a grid than one that does not. There is also an underappreciated portfolio effect. Tidal phase differs between sites around a coastline, so a distributed set of tidal farms can produce a considerably smoother aggregate output than any single one. That argument only works once there are enough farms to aggregate, which is a chicken-and-egg problem the industry has not yet escaped.
What the Auctions Reveal About Cost
The UK's Contracts for Difference auctions award fifteen-year inflation-linked contracts at a strike price, with a dedicated budget ringfenced for tidal stream, which makes them the clearest public record anywhere of what tidal power actually costs.
Converting every round to 2024 prices for comparability, tidal stream cleared at roughly 249 pounds per megawatt hour in Allocation Round 4, 276 in AR5, 240 in AR6 and 265 in AR7, the most recent round. Offshore wind in the same rounds cleared at about 52 pounds, then 80 in AR6 and 91 in AR7.
Two conclusions follow, and they point in different directions, which is why both belong in an honest account.
The first is that tidal stream has not yet demonstrated a cost reduction curve. Four rounds and roughly a decade apart, the real strike price is essentially flat and slightly higher than where it started. Wind and solar achieved their transformations through steep declines of exactly the kind tidal has not yet shown.
The second is that tidal has nonetheless gained ground relative to the alternative; in AR4,4 tidal cost around 4.8 times offshore wind. In AR7 it cost around 2.9 times. The ratio improved, but only because offshore wind got considerably more expensive as interest rates and supply chain costs rose. Tidal held its position in a market where everything else moved against it, which is a more modest claim than cost reduction and not nothing.
Capacity tells a third story. Tidal awards ran 41 megawatts in AR4, 53 in AR5, 28 in AR6 and 21 in AR7. The declining trend reflects arithmetic rather than retreat: the ringfenced budget has been small, at 20 million pounds in AR4, 10 million in AR5 and 15 million in AR6, and a fixed pot at a high strike price buys fewer megawatts. The four projects awarded in AR7, totaling 20.9 megawatts across Welsh and Scottish sites, sat inside a round that delivered a record 14.7 gigawatts overall.
The Hidden Cost Is Maintenance
One factor behind that stubborn cost does not appear in any of the carousel's slides and deserves to, because it shapes the economics more than any other operating variable.
Servicing a machine in a tidal race is extraordinarily difficult. The flow that makes the site valuable also makes it unworkable: divers and remotely operated vehicles cannot operate safely in three meters per second of current. Work happens at slack water, which lasts perhaps thirty to sixty minutes, occurs a few times a day, and must coincide with acceptable weather and a vessel being on station. A job that takes two hours on land becomes a multi-day campaign.
Everything in the water is also under continuous attack. Saltwater corrodes, biofouling accumulates on blades and degrades their hydrodynamics, seals fail, and cavitation erodes blade surfaces. These are solvable engineering problems, but they are expensive to solve, which is why several developers have moved toward floating platforms with retractable rotors, lifting the turbines clear of the water for maintenance rather than sending people down to them.
Why Tidal Power Is Not Everywhere
The carousel's closing slide lists the right three constraints, and the evidence sharpens each.
Suitable sites are rare. Both technologies need specific geography that cannot be manufactured, and unlike wind and solar,r the resource is concentrated into a small number of channels and estuaries. This caps the addressable market before any other consideration.
Costs are high and have not yet fallen. The auction record shows a real strike price near 265 pounds per megawatt-hour, close to three times offshore wind, flat across a decade of rounds.
Environment and maintenance compound the problem. Barrages face objections that no engineering can resolve, since reducing intertidal habitat is inherent to how they work. Tidal stream faces narrower ecological questions and a punishing maintenance environment that keeps operating costs high.
What survives all of that is a real but bounded case. For island and coastal systems with strong flows, expensive alternatives and a need for predictable output, tidal makes sense in a way it does not in a country with cheap onshore wind. The UK's 11 percent of demand is a genuine prize for a technology that produces power on a schedule known decades ahead. The question has never been whether tides can generate electricity, which was settled in Brittany in 1966. The question is whether a technology with a hard resource ceiling can reach the deployment volumes that drive costs down before alternatives get cheap enough that nobody needs it.
Note: This article reflects conditions as of November 2026, drawing on sources including UK Contracts for Difference allocation round results from AR4 to AR7, UK government assessments of Severn Estuary barrage proposals, and published data on La Rance, Sihwa Lake, MeyGen and Morlais. Strike prices have been converted to 2024 prices to compare rounds set on different price bases.

Guest Contributor
Contributor
This article was contributed by an external writer affiliated with our publication.




